Reading past history increases my appreciation of future histories. Geography precedes history. An historian informs us that Russia is a gigantic, austere plain open to eastern winds and Asian migrations, then introduces populations, peasantries, nobilities, cities and so on. We know that we can read about all of these features elsewhere. A future historian introduces planetography and planetary populations and persuades us that we
would be able to read about them elsewhere. Readers with amateur writing abilities can fill in some details with fanfic. (I
can write but not fiction.)
Emil Dalmady comes from the colonized planet, Altai. Later, Dominic Flandry visits that planet. We accept what we are told about its history just as we accept a past historian's account of Russia. The background details do not really exist but Poul Anderson is able to write as if they did.
(Here at Blog Central, we have been busy preparing for four house guests for five nights arriving tomorrow. When they leave, I will visit Andrea above the Old Pier Bookshop. So posts might remain sparse. The spirit is willing but not always the social conditions!)
Kaor, Paul!
ReplyDeleteAnd we learned from "A Message in Secret" that Altai was originally settled by a mix of Russians/Mongols, which sort of ties in with your remarks about Russian history. One book I have is Edward Crankshaw's THE SHADOW OF THE WINTER PALACE, late Tsarist Russia from 1825-1914. A good book, but weak and unsatisfactory ending.
I have thought if Altai was partly settled by Russians, it was odd we don't see their faith as being Russian Orthodoxy. It might have been more realistic if the religion of the Tebtengri clans had been Christianity. If "Message" had been written latter Anderson might have written it that way.
Ad astra! Sean
Kaor, Paul!
ReplyDeleteI have a special affection for both "A Message in Secret" and THE PLAGUE OF MASTERS, two of my most favorite Flandry stories. And "Message" is also the funniest of the Flandry stories, where we see Anderson having some good-humored fun with him. Which does not mean we don't see serious points being seen in that story: like that sidebar on the dangerous evoluton of what were once rats.
Ad astra! Sean
Looking up "Mongolia" on Wikipedia and following links to articles about Religion there I find that "Mongolian Shamanism" currently outnumbers Christianity there. People from Mongolia emigrating to set up a colony that is specifically Mongolian in culture would likely prefer shamanism to Christianity.
ReplyDeleteKaor, Jim!
ReplyDeleteI'm a bit puzzled, I was writing about the Russian element of the settlers who colonized Altai. It would have seemed natural for their faith to be Russian Orthodoxy.
We see mention of how the Tebtengri clans did follow a shamanistic religion, with a religious reverence for Terra mixed in. But most Altaians believed in a Buddhist/Muslim mix codified by Subotai.
Add astra! Sean
Note that Altai is far less weird in the League's time than it is in late Imperial times -- the culture has grown stranger and stranger, not least because the planet was isolated for so long.
ReplyDeleteKaor, Mr. Stirling!
ReplyDeleteI agree, during the 700-800 years between "Esau" and Flandry's mission there, we have to expect cultural/political developments on Altai to diverge drastically from what Emil Dalmady had known. I recall how Oleg Khan himself, conversing with Flandry, made very similar points. Long isolation and adaptation to local conditions will do that.
Ad astra! Sean